Tuesday 7 September 2010

Goodbye to the Diploma in Creative & Media

I went to the final meeting of the Diploma in Creative & Media Diploma Development Partnership yesterday, the Chair of the Higher Education Group more accurately described it as a wake. The imminent death of this, and the other new Diplomas for 14-19 year olds was the elephant in the room that was only ever hinted at with a raised eyebrow or a sly remark. But there's no getting away from the fact that the coalition Government has effectively killed off their implementation.

I've been involved with the development of the Diploma in Creative & Media in a variety of roles over the last 3-4 years, primarily whilst I worked for one of the Sector Skills Councils charged with developing it. Like a number of Government initiatives before it (GNVQ, AVCE, Applied GCSEs and A-levels), this new qualification was aimed to provide students with an applied learning experience that had genuine parity with their better loved siblings, the GCSE and A-level. They were also intended to kill off BTEC, well established qualifications in both Further Education and schools, which are beyond Government control owned as they are by Pearson (the publishing multinational who own the FT, Penguin and many others).

In my view, although the intentions of all those involved were right and good, there were simply too many stakeholders who felt they owned the project, except for certain key moments when it seemed nobody owned the project. QCA, DCSF, the three SSCs and the Awarding Organisations were just some of the key organisations involved, and it was clear that a number of them felt that they knew better than the rest. I'm not so sure that they did... The assessment methodology that was forced onto those developing the qualification, for example, was simply inappropriate.

The coalition Government has opted to remove the entitlement to study the programme that Labour had intended to use to drive up demand for the Diploma. This means that students across England no longer have a right to study the Diploma, which means in turn that market forces will now determine whether or not the qualification will live or die. Given the complexity of the qualification, and the issues with certain components in particular (the Functional Skills for example), it seems clear that the qualification will slowly, painfully disappear.

Which in many ways is a shame. The development of the qualifications was a genuine collaborative effort between a number of organisations and a number of sectors, including Higher Education, Further Education, schools and employers and that this effort now potentially goes to waste is disappointing. The cost of developments to date must be enormous, £521 million across all the the Diplomas was the last figure I heard, and I suspect this doesn't include a further vast amount spent in terms of cash and time by organisations supporting and delivering the qualifications.

Finally, and most importantly, it's a terrible shame for the students who have already taken it or are in the process of taking it. What will they do now with their qualification, and what will they do with them in the future when it's no more than a ripple in the ocean of educational policy?

Ed Balls said that the Diplomas would become the 'qualification of choice', unfortunately for the students who have taken it, perhaps they made the wrong choice.

Brighton Beach - 4th September


Went to a lovely wedding in Brighton last Saturday, took this photo after fish & chips and champagne on the beach. Really beautiful light.

Wednesday 1 September 2010

Manchester - August 2010


Compare and contrast with the Manchester Central Library, the circular building above.  A really beautiful building.

Manchester - August 2010


Here's a better photo of it, one that I 'borrowed' from elsewhere on the web.

Manchester - August 2010


Had a fantastic weekend in Manchester catching up with university friends.  It's fair to say that the city has changed enormously since I was last there.  It was undergoing an amazing amount of redevelopment in the three years that I lived there, and it seems that the frenetic pace of change hasn't let up.

The architecture in the city is superb.  An outstanding mixture of old victorian red-brick buildings and new, sympathetically designed glass and steel structures.  A walk out form the city proper to Salford brought me to the new Civil Justice Centre, which took my breath away.  I only had my iPhone with me, so the picture above doesn't do it any justice whatsoever.  It was designed by Denton Corker Marshall, so check out their website for more information and better photos: www.dentoncorkermarshall.com